4 Different Types of Hot Water Systems

Selecting the right hot water system for your home is essential for ensuring reliable access to hot water while managing energy costs effectively. Hot water systems are a significant investment for any household, as they account for approximately 25% of your home's energy use. The right system can save you money on your energy bills and provide consistent hot water for years to come.

‍

Hot water system efficiency refers to how effectively the system converts energy into hot water. More efficient systems use less energy to heat the same amount of water, resulting in lower running costs and reduced environmental impact.

‍

The design and type of hot water system you choose depends on several factors including your household size, available space, energy sources, and budget. Here are the four main types of hot water systems available in Australia:

‍

1. Electric Hot Water Systems

‍

Electric hot water systems are common in many Australian homes due to their reliable performance and straightforward installation process. These systems heat water using an electric heating element located inside a storage tank.

‍

The working principle of electric hot water systems is simple. Cold water enters the tank and is heated by the electric element to a preset temperature, typically between 60-75°C. The hot water is then stored in the insulated tank until needed.

‍

Key components include the storage tank (usually made of stainless steel or vitreous enamel-lined steel), the heating element, thermostat, anode rod, and pressure relief valve. These systems come in various sizes ranging from 25 to 400 litres to suit different household needs.

‍

Electric hot water systems work optimally when connected to off-peak electricity tariffs, which can significantly reduce running costs. However, they are less energy-efficient than some other options and can be expensive to run on standard electricity rates.

‍

The annual energy use for a typical electric storage system is approximately 3,800-5,000 kWh/year for a four-person household. These systems cost between $500-$1,500 for the unit, with installation adding $300-$700 depending on complexity.

‍

With proper maintenance, including regular anode rod replacement every 5 years, electric hot water systems typically last 10-12 years.

‍

2. Gas Hot Water Systems

‍

Gas hot water systems are highly efficient and cost-effective options for many Brisbane homes, especially those with existing gas connections. These systems use natural gas or LPG to heat water quickly and consistently.

‍

There are two main types of gas hot water systems: storage and continuous flow (instantaneous). Storage systems work similarly to electric models but heat water using a gas burner rather than an electric element. Continuous flow systems heat water on demand as it passes through a heat exchanger, providing endless hot water without the need for a storage tank.

‍

Gas hot water systems operate by igniting a burner when hot water is needed. The heat from the flame is transferred to the water either in the storage tank or through the heat exchanger in instantaneous systems. This process is more energy-efficient than electric resistance heating.

‍

Key components include the gas burner, heat exchanger, thermostat, ignition system, and in storage models, the insulated tank. Continuous flow systems are compact and can be mounted on walls to save space.

‍

Gas systems work best when connected to natural gas mains, though LPG bottles can be used in areas without natural gas access. The optimal working range is similar to electric systems at 60-70°C, but gas systems can heat water much faster.

‍

The annual energy use for gas hot water systems ranges from 15,000-25,000 MJ/year (natural gas) for storage systems, while continuous flow systems use approximately 10,000-20,000 MJ/year, depending on household size and usage patterns.

‍

Gas systems cost between $800-$2,000 for the unit, with installation adding $500-$1,000. Their typical lifespan is 10-15 years, with continuous flow systems often lasting longer than storage models.

‍

3. Solar Hot Water Systems

‍

Solar hot water systems are an environmentally friendly option that harnesses renewable energy to heat water, reducing electricity costs and greenhouse gas emissions. These systems are becoming increasingly popular in sunny Brisbane, where abundant solar resources make them highly effective.

‍

Solar hot water systems work by using solar collectors (either flat panels or evacuated tubes) to absorb heat from the sun. This heat is transferred to water circulating through the system. The heated water is then stored in an insulated tank for later use. Most systems include an electric or gas booster to ensure hot water is available during periods of low sunlight.

‍

Key components include solar collectors, a storage tank, a circulation pump (for some systems), a controller, and the boosting element. Solar systems come in two main designs: thermosiphon (tank mounted above the collectors) and split systems (tank at ground level).

‍

Solar hot water systems work optimally in areas with good solar exposure and properly oriented roof space. In Brisbane, north-facing installations typically yield the best results. The systems operate most efficiently during sunny days but can still collect significant heat on cloudy days, especially evacuated tube models.

‍

The annual energy use for the boosting element in a solar hot water system is approximately 1,000-2,000 kWh/year for electric boosters or 4,000-8,000 MJ/year for gas boosters, representing savings of 60-80% compared to conventional systems.

‍

Solar hot water systems are more expensive upfront, ranging from $3,000-$7,000 installed, but government rebates and incentives can reduce this cost. With proper maintenance, these systems can last 15-20 years, with collectors typically needing replacement earlier than tanks.

‍

4. Heat Pump Hot Water Systems

‍

Heat pump hot water systems represent advanced technology that combines energy efficiency with reliable performance. Instead of generating heat directly, these systems extract heat from the surrounding air and transfer it to the water, similar to how a refrigerator works but in reverse.

‍

Heat pumps operate by using a refrigerant that absorbs heat from the ambient air. The refrigerant is compressed, raising its temperature further, and this heat is transferred to the water via a heat exchanger. This process uses significantly less electricity than conventional electric resistance heating.

‍

Key components include the compressor, evaporator, condenser (heat exchanger), expansion valve, fan, refrigerant circuit, and storage tank. Most systems are integrated units with the heat pump mounted on top of or beside the storage tank.

‍

Heat pump systems work best in moderate to warm climates like Brisbane, where they can operate efficiently year-round. They perform optimally when the ambient temperature is above 5°C, making them extremely suitable for Queensland's climate. Some models are designed to work effectively even in colder conditions.

‍

The annual energy use for heat pump systems is approximately 1,000-1,500 kWh/year for a four-person household, which is about 30% of the energy used by conventional electric systems.

‍

Heat pump systems typically cost between $2,500-$4,000 installed, and they may qualify for government rebates. Their lifespan is usually 10-15 years, with the heat pump component sometimes requiring replacement before the tank.

‍

How to Choose the Best Hot Water System Type

‍

Choosing the right hot water system involves balancing several key factors to find the option that best meets your specific needs. The ideal hot water system for your home depends primarily on household size, local climate, available energy sources, budget constraints, and installation space.

‍

For household size, larger families need systems with greater capacity or faster recovery rates. A family of four typically requires a minimum 160-litre storage tank or a continuous flow system rated at 20+ litres per minute.

‍

Climate is another decisive factor, particularly for solar and heat pump systems. Solar performs exceptionally well in sunny regions like Queensland, while heat pumps operate most efficiently in moderate to warm climates and may struggle in areas that experience frequent freezing temperatures.

‍

Your available energy sources significantly narrow your options. Homes without natural gas connections must choose between electric, LPG, solar, or heat pump systems. If you have existing gas lines, gas systems often provide more economical operation compared to standard electric rates.

‍

Budget considerations cover both upfront costs and long-term running expenses. Electric storage systems have the lowest initial cost but highest running costs, while solar systems offer the opposite trade-off with high initial investment but minimal operating expenses.

‍

Installation space requirements vary significantly between system types. Continuous flow systems require minimal space as they can be wall-mounted externally. Storage systems need floor space for tanks, and solar systems require suitable roof area with proper orientation.

‍

What Are the Criteria to Consider When Choosing a Hot Water System Type?

‍

When selecting a hot water system, several criteria should be carefully evaluated to ensure you make the most suitable choice for your specific circumstances:

‍

• Hot Water Demand: This refers to the volume of hot water your household uses daily. It's determined by the number of people in your home and their usage patterns (frequency of showers, baths, dishwashing, etc.).
• Energy Efficiency Rating: The energy efficiency of a hot water system indicates how effectively it converts energy into hot water. Higher star ratings mean lower running costs and reduced environmental impact.
• Installation Requirements: Different systems have varying installation needs regarding space, positioning, access to energy sources, and pipe configurations.
• Running Costs: This includes the ongoing expenses for fuel (electricity, gas, solar) and maintenance requirements over the system's lifetime.
• Water Quality: The mineral content in your local water supply affects system longevity and maintenance requirements, particularly for storage systems.
• Available Rebates: Government incentives and rebates may be available for energy-efficient options like solar and heat pump systems, affecting the overall cost calculation.
• Recovery Rate: The speed at which a system can heat a new tank of water after the stored hot water has been used is important for meeting continuous demand.
• System Lifespan: Different system types have varying expected lifespans, affecting the long-term value proposition.
• Backup Options: For solar systems, the type and capacity of backup heating when insufficient sunlight is available must be considered.
• Future Plans: Consider how long you plan to stay in your current home, as this affects which system offers the best return on investment.

‍

What Is the Most Cost-Effective Hot Water System Type?

‍

Heat pump and solar hot water systems are the most cost-effective options when considering the total cost over the system's lifespan. Though they require higher initial investments, their significantly lower operating costs result in substantial savings over time.

‍

A typical heat pump system costs approximately $2,500-$4,000 upfront but uses only about $300-$450 per year in electricity, whereas a standard electric system costs $800-$1,500 initially but consumes $1,000-$1,500 annually in electricity. Over a 10-year period, the heat pump's total cost amounts to $5,500-$8,500 compared to $10,800-$16,500 for the standard electric system—representing potential savings of $5,300-$8,000.

‍

Solar hot water systems have the highest initial cost at $3,000-$7,000 but lowest running costs at approximately $150-$250 per year for boosting. Over their 15-20 year lifespan, they typically save $10,000-$15,000 in energy costs compared to conventional electric systems. These systems also qualify for the most significant government rebates, including Small-scale Technology Certificates (STCs), which can reduce the upfront cost by $500-$1,500 depending on the system size and location.

‍

Maintenance costs vary by system type. Electric and gas storage systems require periodic anode replacement (approximately $250-$400 every 5 years). Solar systems need collector cleaning and glycol replacement in closed-loop systems (roughly $200-$300 every 5 years). Heat pumps require refrigerant checks and occasional fan maintenance (about $150-$300 every 3-5 years).

‍

Instantaneous gas systems are moderately cost-effective, with middle-range purchase prices ($900-$2,000) and running costs, particularly when connected to natural gas rather than LPG. Their long lifespan (12-15 years) and minimal maintenance requirements enhance their lifetime value.

‍

What Is the Cheapest Hot Water System Type?

‍

Electric storage hot water systems are definitively the cheapest option based on initial purchase and installation costs. A basic electric storage system can be purchased for as little as $500-$800 with installation adding $300-$700, making the total upfront cost approximately $800-$1,500—significantly less than any other system type.

‍

However, these systems have the highest ongoing operating costs, particularly when not connected to off-peak tariffs. The low upfront cost is offset by electricity expenses that can reach $1,000-$1,500 annually for a four-person household, making them the most expensive option over the system's lifespan.

‍

What Is the Most Expensive Hot Water System Type?

‍

Solar hot water systems with electric or gas boosters are the most expensive hot water systems to purchase and install. High-end evacuated tube solar hot water systems with a 300-400L storage capacity can cost between $5,000-$9,000 for equipment and installation combined, making them the highest initial investment among all hot water system types.

‍

The premium price reflects several factors: complex equipment including solar collectors (either flat panels or evacuated tubes), specially designed storage tanks with heat exchangers, circulation pumps, controllers, and boosting elements. Split system configurations with ground-level tanks require additional pumps and controllers, further increasing costs.

‍

Installation costs for solar systems are also significantly higher than other types, typically ranging from $1,500-$3,000, due to the specialized skills required. The installation process involves roof mounting of collectors, structural reinforcement if needed, complex plumbing connections between collectors and tanks, electrical connections for pumps and boosters, and in some cases, crane hire for lifting heavy components onto roofs.

‍

For evacuated tube systems with gas boosters and advanced features like frost protection for colder regions, the price can reach up to $10,000 for large households. However, these systems often qualify for the most substantial government rebates and deliver the lowest ongoing operational costs, which can offset the high initial investment over their 15-20 year lifespan.

‍

What Are the Energy Efficiency Ratings for Different Hot Water System Types?

‍

Energy efficiency ratings for hot water systems in Australia are standardized using a star rating system, with more stars indicating higher efficiency. These ratings help consumers compare the energy performance of different system types and models.

‍

The energy efficiency rating represents how effectively a hot water system converts its energy source (electricity, gas, solar, etc.) into useful hot water. Higher ratings indicate less energy wastage and lower running costs. In Australia, ratings are typically displayed as a number of stars (1-10 for some systems) or as a Standardised Energy Consumption (SEC) figure, which estimates annual energy consumption based on standardized usage patterns.

‍

Energy Efficiency Ratings by System Type:

‍

Electric Storage Systems:

• Star Rating: Typically 1-3 stars
• Energy Efficiency: Low to moderate
• Annual Energy Consumption: 3,800-5,000 kWh for a typical four-person household
• Notes: Efficiency can be improved with better tank insulation and off-peak operation

‍

Gas Storage Systems:

• Star Rating: Usually 3-5 stars
• Energy Efficiency: Moderate
• Annual Energy Consumption: 15,000-25,000 MJ (natural gas)
• Notes: 5-star rated models feature better insulation and more efficient burners

‍

Gas Continuous Flow Systems:

• Star Rating: 5-7 stars
• Energy Efficiency: High
• Annual Energy Consumption: 10,000-20,000 MJ (natural gas)
• Notes: No standby heat loss as water is only heated when needed

‍

Heat Pump Systems:

• Star Rating: 6-10 stars
• Energy Efficiency: Very high
• Annual Energy Consumption: 1,000-1,500 kWh
• Notes: Can be 3-4 times more efficient than standard electric systems

‍

Solar Hot Water Systems:

• Star Rating: 8-10 stars (for the solar component)
• Energy Efficiency: Extremely high
• Annual Energy Consumption for Boosting: 1,000-2,000 kWh (electric) or 4,000-8,000 MJ (gas)
• Notes: Efficiency varies with location, system design, and available sunlight

‍

Electric Continuous Flow Systems:

• Star Rating: 2-3 stars
• Energy Efficiency: Low
• Annual Energy Consumption: 3,500-4,500 kWh
• Notes: Less common due to high power requirements and running costs

‍

Heat Pump Systems with Smart Controls:

• Star Rating: Up to 10 stars
• Energy Efficiency: Extremely high
• Annual Energy Consumption: 800-1,200 kWh
• Notes: Advanced models with smart controls can optimize energy use based on usage patterns and ambient temperatures

‍

What Hot Water System Type Requires Less Maintenance?

‍

Regular maintenance is an important consideration when selecting a hot water system, as it affects both long-term costs and reliability. Different systems have varying maintenance requirements based on their complexity and components. Here's a ranking of hot water systems from lowest to highest maintenance needs:

‍

• Tankless Gas Water Heaters: Minimal preventative maintenance, typically requiring only an annual flush to remove mineral buildup. These systems have no tank to corrode and fewer components that can fail.
• Electric Storage Tanks: Infrequent servicing needs due to simple design. Main maintenance involves checking the anode rod every 3-5 years and occasional element replacement after 7-10 years.
• Gas Storage: Periodic burner and tank check required, usually annually. Sediment buildup needs to be addressed and thermocouple may need replacement every few years.
• Heat Pump Systems: Air filter and compressor inspection needed every 1-2 years. Evaporator coils require cleaning to maintain efficiency, and refrigerant levels should be checked periodically.
• Solar Hot Water: Requires routine check of collector panels and booster system. Glass surfaces need cleaning, glycol fluid replacement (in closed systems), and more complex components mean more maintenance points.

‍

What Are the Different Design Types for Hot Water Systems?

‍

Understanding the various design configurations available for hot water systems helps in selecting the most suitable option for your specific household needs. Each design offers distinct advantages in terms of installation requirements, space utilization, and performance characteristics.

‍

The design type of a hot water system refers to its fundamental configuration and method of storing and/or heating water. Each design type offers distinct advantages for different household needs and installation constraints.

‍

Storage Tank Systems:

• Configuration: Large insulated tank (typically 50-400L) that stores and maintains hot water
• Operation: Water is heated and kept hot until needed
• Variants: Available in electric, gas, solar, and heat pump configurations
• Best For: Households with moderate, consistent hot water needs
• Limitations: Limited capacity; can run out during heavy usage

‍

Continuous Flow/Instantaneous Systems:

• Configuration: Compact wall-mounted units without storage tanks
• Operation: Heats water on demand as it flows through the unit
• Variants: Primarily gas-powered, with some electric models available
• Best For: Households with variable demand or limited installation space
• Limitations: Maximum flow rate limitations; may struggle with simultaneous usage points

‍

Solar Hot Water Designs:

• Thermosiphon Systems:
  
  • Configuration: Roof-mounted tank positioned above solar collectors
  • Operation: Natural water circulation without pumps
  • Best For: Simple installation, reliable operation in warm climates
• Split Systems:
  
  • Configuration: Ground-level tank with roof-mounted collectors
  • Operation: Pump-driven circulation
  • Best For: Areas with weight restrictions for roofing or frost-prone regions

‍

Heat Pump Configurations:

• Integrated Units:
  
  • Configuration: Heat pump mounted directly on or beside the storage tank
  • Operation: All-in-one system for simplified installation
  • Best For: Areas with limited space
• Split Heat Pump Systems:
  
  • Configuration: Separate heat pump unit connected to remote storage tank
  • Operation: Allows flexible positioning of components
  • Best For: Optimizing heat pump performance in varying climate conditions

‍

Unvented vs. Vented Systems:

• Unvented/Mains Pressure Systems:
  
  • Configuration: Sealed systems operating at mains water pressure
  • Operation: Delivers high-pressure hot water throughout the home
  • Best For: Modern homes with multiple bathrooms
• Vented/Low-Pressure Systems:
  
  • Configuration: Connected to a header tank, operates at gravity pressure
  • Operation: Water pressure depends on height of header tank
  • Best For: Older properties with existing vented setups

‍

Combination/Multi-Energy Systems:

• Configuration: Systems that can utilize multiple energy sources
• Operation: Primary heating method with backup options
• Example: Solar with gas or electric boosting
• Best For: Maximizing efficiency while ensuring continuous hot water availability

‍

Tankless Water Heater System

‍

Tankless water heater systems, also known as continuous flow or instantaneous systems, are compact units that heat water directly without the need for a storage tank. These space-saving systems provide hot water on demand, eliminating standby heat loss associated with storage tanks.

‍

These systems work by activating when a hot water tap is opened. Cold water flows through a pipe into the unit, where it is heated rapidly by either a gas burner or electric heating elements. The water is heated to the preset temperature as it passes through the heat exchanger, providing continuous hot water for as long as needed, limited only by the unit's flow rate capacity.

‍

The working principles of tankless systems involve sophisticated flow sensors that detect water movement and trigger the heating process. When hot water is requested, sensors measure the incoming water temperature and flow rate, and the system's controller adjusts the energy input to achieve the desired output temperature. Advanced models feature modulating burners or variable-power electrical elements that adjust their output based on demand, ensuring consistent temperature regardless of flow rate variations.

‍

Tankless water heaters are primarily powered by two energy sources:

‍

• Natural Gas/LPG: Gas-powered units are more common and can deliver higher flow rates (typically 15-30 litres per minute). They require proper ventilation and gas connections but offer lower operating costs and faster heating capabilities.
• Electricity: Electric tankless systems are simpler to install but typically provide lower flow rates (7-15 litres per minute) and require substantial electrical capacity (often 40-80 amps). They are ideal for point-of-use applications or smaller households with modest hot water demands.

‍

Storage Tank Water Heater System

‍

Storage tank water heater systems are the traditional and most common type of water heating system in Australian homes. These systems consist of an insulated tank that holds a specific volume of hot water (typically 50-400 litres) ready for use at any time.

‍

The system works by maintaining a reservoir of hot water at a preset temperature (usually 60-75°C). Cold water enters the bottom of the tank through the dip tube, where it is heated by an energy source located at the bottom or side of the tank. As water heats, it rises to the top of the tank due to convection. When hot water is drawn from the top of the tank, cold water automatically enters the bottom to maintain the tank's volume, triggering the heating system to activate.

‍

The working principles involve a thermostat that monitors water temperature and activates the heating mechanism when temperature falls below the set point. The tank features insulation to minimize heat loss, a pressure relief valve for safety, and an anode rod to protect against corrosion. Some models include stratification technology that maintains temperature layers within the tank to improve efficiency.

‍

Storage tank water heaters can be powered by various energy sources:

‍

• Electricity: Electric elements (typically 1.8-4.8 kW) provide reliable heating and are available with off-peak timers to take advantage of lower electricity rates.
• Natural Gas/LPG: Gas burners heat water more quickly than electric elements and generally have lower running costs, especially with natural gas connections.
• Solar Energy: Solar collectors heat a transfer fluid that circulates through a heat exchanger in the storage tank, with electric or gas boosting for periods of insufficient sunlight.
• Heat Pump Technology: Heat pump tanks extract heat from surrounding air and transfer it to water in the tank, using 60-70% less electricity than conventional electric systems.

‍

Combination Boiler System

‍

Combination boiler systems, commonly known as combi boilers, are versatile units that provide both hot water and space heating from a single compact appliance. These systems are increasingly popular in Australia for their space efficiency and ability to deliver hot water on demand without the need for a separate storage tank.

‍

The combi boiler works as a dual-function device that heats water directly from the mains when hot water is requested and also circulates heated water through radiators or underfloor heating systems for space heating. Unlike traditional systems that require a separate water cylinder and header tank, combi boilers are all-in-one solutions that heat water only when needed, similar to tankless systems.

‍

The working principles involve a primary heat exchanger that heats water for the central heating circuit and a secondary heat exchanger that provides domestic hot water. When a hot water tap is opened, the boiler detects the flow and diverts its full heating power to the secondary heat exchanger, prioritizing hot water delivery over space heating. Advanced models feature sophisticated electronic controls that manage the transition between heating modes and modulate output based on demand.

‍

Combination boiler systems are typically powered by these energy sources:

‍

• Natural Gas: The most common fuel for combi boilers, offering efficient operation and lower running costs where natural gas is available.
• LPG (Liquid Petroleum Gas): An alternative for properties without natural gas connections, requiring conversion kits or purpose-built LPG models.
• Electricity: Electric combi boilers are available but less common due to higher operating costs; they're suitable for properties without gas supply and are simpler to install without flue requirements.
• Oil: Oil-fired combi boilers are an option for rural properties without gas connections, requiring external oil storage and regular deliveries.

‍

Condensing Water Heater

‍

Condensing water heaters represent the latest advancement in water heating technology, designed to maximize energy efficiency by capturing heat that would otherwise be lost through exhaust gases. These high-efficiency systems can achieve energy ratings of up to 98%, making them among the most economical options available.

‍

The condensing water heater works by extracting additional heat from combustion gases before they exit the system. Unlike conventional water heaters where exhaust gases can reach temperatures of 180-230°C, condensing units cool these gases to approximately 55°C, causing water vapor in the exhaust to condense and release latent heat. This reclaimed heat is transferred to the incoming cold water, significantly improving efficiency.

‍

The working principles involve a secondary heat exchanger specifically designed to withstand acidic condensate. When hot combustion gases pass through this heat exchanger, they cool below the dew point, causing water vapor to condense and release additional heat energy. The system requires proper drainage for the acidic condensate and typically features a fan-assisted flue system that can be vented horizontally, offering flexible installation options.

‍

Condensing water heaters are available in both storage tank and tankless configurations, powered by these primary energy sources:

‍

• Natural Gas: Most common fuel type for condensing water heaters, offering the best efficiency improvements over non-condensing models.
• LPG: Available for properties without natural gas connections, with similar high-efficiency performance.
• Electric (Heat Pump Condensing): Not technically condensing in the same way as gas models, but heat pump water heaters achieve similar efficiency improvements by extracting heat from ambient air rather than generating it directly.
• Hybrid Systems: Some advanced models can integrate with solar thermal systems for even greater efficiency, using solar energy as the primary heat source with gas condensing technology as backup.

‍