Global
Solar Hot Water Systems vs Gas Hot Water Systems

September 8, 2021

Mitchell Plumbing & Gas

Solar Hot Water Systems vs Gas Hot Water Systems

When Brisbane homeowners need to install a new hot water system, we at Mitchell Plumbing & Gas know that choosing between solar and gas options can be tricky. Solar hot water systems use the sun's energy to heat your water, while gas hot water systems burn natural gas or LPG to warm up your home's water supply.

These two systems work in completely different ways, which means they each have their own set of advantages and trade-offs. To help you make the best choice for your home, we look at how they compare across several important areas:

  • Energy Use: Solar hot water systems tap into free sunlight to heat your water, while gas hot water systems need a steady supply of gas. This affects both your energy bills and environmental impact.
  • Installation Costs: The upfront price of putting in each hot water system can vary quite a bit. Solar hot water systems often cost more to install at first, but they can save money over time.
  • Maintenance Needs: Each hot water system needs different kinds of care to keep running well. Some parts might need checking or replacing more often than others.
  • How Long They Last: Different hot water systems have different lifespans, which affects their long-term value for your home.
  • Noise Levels: Some hot water systems are quieter than others, which matters if the unit will be near bedrooms or living areas.
  • Heat-Up Speed: Compare storage recovery and continuous-flow output separately. The time hot water takes to reach a tap also depends on the pipework between the heater and the outlet.

‍

What Is a Solar Hot Water System?

A solar hot water system turns sunlight into heat for your home's water supply. The hot water system works by having solar collectors (panels) on your roof that soak up the sun's rays. These panels have special tubes or flat plates that heat up the water as it moves through them. The heated water then flows down to a storage tank, where it stays hot until you need it.

The main parts of a solar hot water system are:

  • Solar panels that catch the sun's energy
  • A well-insulated storage tank to keep the water hot
  • Backup electric or gas boosters for cloudy days
  • Pipes that connect everything together

‍

What Is a Gas Hot Water System?

A gas hot water system heats water using natural gas or LPG (Liquid Petroleum Gas). When you turn on your hot water tap, cold water flows into the hot water system where a gas burner heats it up straight away. If you're using a storage hot water system, the gas burner keeps a tank of water hot and ready to use.

The key parts include:

  • A gas burner that heats the water
  • A storage tank (for storage hot water systems) or heat exchanger (for continuous flow)
  • Temperature controls to keep the water at the right heat
  • Gas connection and safety devices

‍

What Are The Differences Between Solar Hot Water Systems and Gas Hot Water Systems?

At Mitchell Plumbing & Gas, we regularly explain to Brisbane homeowners how solar and gas hot water systems differ in several key ways:

When looking at how these hot water systems create hot water, they use very different energy sources:

  • Solar hot water systems collect energy from sunlight through roof-mounted panels
  • Gas hot water systems burn natural gas or LPG to create heat
  • Solar hot water systems need a backup power source for cloudy days
  • Gas hot water systems need a gas supply and, for models with mains-powered ignition or controls, electricity.

Compare the complete systems rather than a fixed efficiency percentage:

  • Solar contribution varies with climate, installation and demand
  • Gas efficiency depends on the selected model
  • Solar contribution is different from sunlight-to-heat conversion efficiency
  • Compare energy use for the same hot-water demand

The setup requirements for each hot water system have notable differences:

  • Solar hot water systems need roof space and specific panel positioning
  • Gas models have specific siting, ventilation, flue and service-access requirements
  • Solar installations take longer and need more roof work
  • Gas hot water systems often have simpler installation requirements

When comparing costs, several factors come into play:

  • Solar hot water systems can cost more upfront and may lower water-heating bills
  • Gas hot water systems cost less to install but have ongoing gas bills
  • Eligible solar hot water installations may qualify for STCs; check the model and scheme requirements
  • Gas prices can change, affecting long-term running costs

‍

Energy Efficiency Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

Solar collectors heat water using sunlight. Their contribution varies with conditions; gas or electric boosting supplies additional heat when needed. Rheem's solar FAQs explain cloudy-weather boosting and climate suitability.

Gas storage and continuous-flow systems work differently. Storage systems also replace heat lost from the tank. A single conversion percentage does not describe every model's energy use.

For a useful comparison, consider:

  • Collector position, shading and local climate
  • How much hot water the household uses
  • Booster fuel and how often boosting is needed
  • Heat losses from tanks and pipework

‍

Installation Costs Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

The installation costs of hot water hot water systems include everything needed to get your new hot water system up and running, from the unit price to labour and additional materials.

When it comes to initial purchase and setup costs, solar hot water systems are a bigger investment upfront. The setup includes the solar panels, storage tank, and all the mounting equipment needed for the roof installation. Gas hot water systems, on the other hand, are more budget-friendly at first.

Some solar hot water installations are eligible for Small-scale Technology Certificates (STCs). Eligibility depends on the listed model and scheme installation requirements, including applicable installer licensing. A registered agent may offer a purchase-price discount in exchange for the right to create the STCs; the amount is not fixed by the regulator. Check the Clean Energy Regulator's water-heater guidance and ask for any STC discount to be identified in your quote.

Solar hot water can reduce purchased energy for water heating, but there is no fixed annual saving for every home. Compare the selected systems using your hot water demand, sunlight, booster use, gas and electricity tariffs, and maintenance needs. Include any continuing gas supply charges when comparing total bills. Rheem's running-cost estimator explains its assumptions and excludes fixed supply charges; use it as an estimate, not a guaranteed bill.

‍

Required Maintenance Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

Maintenance is essential for keeping your hot water system working safely and efficiently. Each type of hot water system has its own maintenance needs and schedules.

Solar hot water systems need collector care and servicing according to the manufacturer's instructions and local conditions. Have a qualified technician assess the collectors, roof mounting, tank and connections. Follow the model's relief-valve and anode maintenance schedule, and arrange professional help where components cannot be reached safely. Solahart's thermosiphon owner's guide gives one model-specific example.

Gas hot water systems need professional servicing according to the manufacturer's schedule. In Queensland, gas servicing, testing and repairs must be done by a licensed gasfitter. This includes work on burners and gas safety controls. Any thermocouple inspection or replacement should follow the model's service instructions, rather than a universal two-to-three-year replacement rule. For storage systems, follow the owner's guide for relief-valve maintenance.

Maintenance frequency depends on the selected model and water conditions. Follow its owner's guide for routine checks and professional servicing. Only carry out maintenance identified for owners where safely accessible; relief-valve discharge can scald, and its drain must never be blocked. Ask a licensed plumber if access or operation is unsafe or unclear.

‍

Average Lifespan Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

A hot water system's lifespan refers to how long it will reliably provide hot water before needing replacement. This timeframe helps homeowners plan for future replacements and understand the long-term value of their investment.

Solar hot water systems do not have one fixed service life. The collectors, storage tank and any booster are parts of the complete system, and water conditions, usage and the model's maintenance requirements all matter.

Gas hot water systems should not be assumed to have a shorter service life solely because they use a burner. Compare the selected models and their condition rather than applying a blanket solar-versus-gas lifespan ranking.

Manufacturer guidance identifies water chemistry, pressure, water temperatures and usage patterns as factors affecting service life. Examples include Solahart's split-solar owner's guide (page 17) and Rheem's gas-storage owner's guide (page 15). Follow the maintenance guidance for the particular model; these examples do not establish a universal replacement age.

‍

Heat-up Time Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

Storage recovery describes reheating water in a tank after hot water is used. Continuous-flow systems heat water on demand and have no storage tank to reheat. Rheem explains these system types.

Solar heating depends on available sunlight, collector conditions and hot water use. Gas or electric boosting supplies extra heat when required. Booster heating time depends on the selected model, water temperature and booster arrangement; it should not be presented as one fixed time to heat every full tank.

The time needed to reheat water in a gas storage tank depends on the volume being reheated, the model's recovery rating and the temperature rise required. Continuous-flow gas systems heat water as it passes through the unit; their delivery capacity depends on the model and operating conditions.

Gas heating does not rely on direct sunlight, while solar systems combine stored solar heat with boosting when needed. For either option, compare the selected system's output and controls with when and how much hot water your household uses.

‍

Noise Levels Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

Noise levels in hot water systems refer to the sound produced during operation, which can affect the comfort of people living in or near the home. Understanding these noise differences helps in deciding where to place your hot water system.

Solar hot water systems are not always silent. Pumped systems have a circulation pump, and the booster may use gas or electricity. Rinnai's split-solar manual describes possible collector noises during high solar gain. Solar heating alone does not guarantee that a system near a bedroom or living area will be inaudible.

Gas hot water systems can make sounds when the burner ignites. Models and installations differ, so compare the selected appliance and any solar booster rather than assuming all gas systems are noisier.

‍

Environmental Impact Differences Between Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems

Solar collectors use renewable sunlight, but the complete system is not emission-free. Its operating emissions depend on booster fuel and energy use.

Burning natural gas or LPG produces direct carbon emissions. Electric boosting can cause indirect emissions from electricity generation. The Clean Energy Regulator explains these emissions categories.

Compare specific systems for the same household demand. Include booster use and electricity supply; operating emissions alone do not measure the full environmental impact.

‍

What Are The Overall Pros And Cons When Comparing Solar and Gas Hot Water Systems?

Here's what we consider the key advantages and disadvantages of each hot water system based on our experience servicing Brisbane homes:

When looking at the overall performance of solar hot water systems, these are the main points to consider:

  • Works best in sunny Brisbane conditions
  • Higher upfront installation costs
  • Noise depends on the system, booster and installation
  • Potential water-heating bill savings, depending on the system and household
  • May reduce operating emissions, depending on boosting and the system replaced
  • Needs backup hot water system for cloudy days
  • Solar heating varies with available sunlight and boosting
  • More complex installation process

For gas hot water systems, here are the key factors that affect their performance:

  • Storage recovery and continuous-flow output depend on the selected model
  • Lower initial setup costs
  • Some operational noise
  • Ongoing gas bill expenses
  • Produces carbon emissions
  • Simple installation process
  • Works in any weather

‍

What Are The Advantages Of Solar Hot Water Systems When Compared To Gas Hot Water Systems?

Solar hot water systems offer several benefits that make them an attractive option for Brisbane homeowners, especially those looking to reduce their environmental impact and long-term costs.

Here are the main benefits that set solar hot water systems apart:

  • May reduce water-heating bills; actual savings depend on usage, boosting and tariffs
  • Use sunlight to reduce purchased energy, while boosting can still require gas or electricity
  • Can reduce purchased energy and associated emissions
  • May qualify for STCs if the model and installation meet scheme requirements
  • Need less frequent maintenance
  • Work well in Brisbane's sunny climate
  • Add value to your property

‍

What Are The Advantages Of Gas Hot Water Systems When Compared To Solar Hot Water Systems?

Gas hot water systems have distinct benefits that make them suitable for certain households, particularly those needing reliable hot water access regardless of weather conditions.

These are the key advantages of choosing a gas hot water system:

  • Continuous-flow models heat water as it is used
  • Gas heating does not depend on sunlight
  • Costs less to purchase and install
  • Suits homes with limited roof space
  • Easy to replace existing gas hot water systems
  • Simple to maintain and service
  • Location must meet the selected gas model's installation requirements

‍

Recent Post

Will a Dehumidifier Dry Out Damp Walls in Brisbane Homes?

Will a Dehumidifier Dry Out Damp Walls in Brisbane Homes?

October 4, 2022
Mitchell Plumbing & Gas

It's not often that you hear the words "dehumidifier" and "plumbing" in the same sentence, but in this case, they go together like bacon and eggs.

How does Hot water heater work?

How does Hot water heater work?

May 27, 2025
Mitchell Plumbing & Gas

Understanding how your hot water heater works helps you maintain reliable hot water and recognize when professional help is needed. These essential household appliances use energy transfer from electricity, gas, or solar power to heat cold water from your main supply, storing it for daily use in showers, dishwashing, and laundry. The basic working principle involves heating water molecules that naturally rise within the storage tank - electric systems use submerged heating elements, gas units burn fuel beneath the tank, solar collectors capture sunlight energy, and heat pump systems extract warmth from surrounding air.

What Is a Hot Water Heater Expansion Tank and Why Is It Important?

What Is a Hot Water Heater Expansion Tank and Why Is It Important?

July 8, 2025
Mitchell Plumbing & Gas

Ever heard those mysterious banging noises from your hot water system or found unexpected leaks around your heater? You might be dealing with pressure problems that an expansion tank could solve. Most Brisbane homeowners don't realize that when water heats up, it expands and needs somewhere to go. Without an expansion tank, this extra pressure can damage pipes, stress your water heater, and lead to expensive repairs.