Global
Gas vs Electric Hot Water Systems

September 8, 2021

Mitchell Plumbing & Gas

Gas vs Electric Hot Water Systems

At Mitchell Plumbing & Gas, we know that both gas and electric hot water systems offer different benefits for Brisbane homes. Gas hot water systems use natural gas or LPG to heat water, while electric hot water systems rely on electric heating elements. These hot water systems differ in several ways:

  • Energy use and running costs
  • Initial setup and installation costs
  • How much upkeep they need
  • How many years they last
  • How quiet or noisy they are
  • How fast they heat your water

‍

What Is a Gas Hot Water System?

A gas hot water system uses natural gas or LPG (Liquefied Petroleum Gas) as its heat source to warm up your water. When you need hot water, the hot water system pulls cold water into a tank where a gas burner heats it up.

The main parts that make up a gas hot water system are:

  • The gas burner sits at the bottom of the tank and makes a flame that heats the water above it. This burner works with either natural gas from the mains or LPG from bottles.
  • The storage tank is where your hot water stays until you need it. The tank has thick insulation to keep the water hot.
  • The temperature control keeps your water at the right heat. It watches the water temperature and turns the burner on when the water gets too cold.

These hot water systems are found in many Brisbane homes and businesses. A gas hot water system can heat water quickly, which is good for busy households that use lots of hot water. Gas hot water systems work well in both small homes and large buildings because they come in different sizes to match how much hot water you need.

‍

What Is an Electric Hot Water System?

An electric hot water system uses electrical heating elements to warm up your water. When cold water enters the tank, electric elements turn energy into heat, much like how your kettle works but on a bigger scale. These hot water systems measure their power use in kilowatt-hours (kWh), which is what you see on your power bill.

The main parts of an electric hot water system include:

  • The heating elements are metal rods that get hot when electricity flows through them. Most tanks have two elements - one at the top and one at the bottom - to heat water evenly.
  • The storage tank holds your heated water and has thick insulation to keep the heat in. These tanks come in many sizes to suit different homes.
  • The thermostat works like a switch that turns the elements on and off to keep your water at the right temperature. It makes sure you don't waste power heating water that's already hot enough.

In Brisbane homes and small shops, electric hot water systems are a common choice. They're straightforward to use and can fit in many spots around your property. Suitable electric storage systems can use controlled-load tariffs or timers to manage running costs. Availability, supply hours and model compatibility need to be checked with the retailer and installer.

‍

What Are The Differences Between Gas And Electric Hot Water Systems?

Gas and electric hot water systems differ in their installation requirements and running costs. Compare the selected models using your current electricity or gas rates, hot water demand and any supply charges. Heat pumps and electric systems using rooftop solar should also be included in the comparison.

When it comes to maintenance, electric hot water systems are simpler to look after because they have fewer moving parts. Gas hot water systems need regular checks of their gas connections and burners. Service life varies with the model, water conditions, usage and maintenance.

Storage reheating time depends on the model, the amount of water being reheated and the temperature rise required. Gas storage systems can recover faster than electric storage systems, but neither has one full-tank heating time. For noise, compare the specific models and installation locations rather than assuming that every electric system is quieter.

‍

Energy Consumption Differences Between Gas And Electric Hot Water Systems

At Mitchell Plumbing & Gas, we see that gas hot water systems in Brisbane homes use either natural gas from the mains or LPG from bottles to make heat. Electric hot water  systems, on the other hand, use power from the electricity grid to heat their elements.

Energy use and running cost are different measures. Electric resistance elements convert electricity directly to heat, while gas systems lose some heat through combustion and exhaust. Heat pumps use electricity to move heat from the air. Compare each complete system, including storage losses, against the same hot water demand and current energy tariffs.

‍

Installation Costs Differences Between Gas And Electric Hot Water Systems

Installation costs include everything needed to get your new hot water system up and running. This covers the price of the unit itself, all the parts needed, and the work to put it in.

Gas hot water systems often cost more to install at first because:

  • They need special gas pipes and fittings
  • They must have proper ventilation and flues
  • A licensed gas fitter has to connect them
  • Extra safety checks are needed

For an electric resistance storage installation, check:

  • The selected model's electrical supply and connection requirements
  • The plumbing connections and specified safety devices
  • A suitable location with safe service access and the required clearances
  • Drainage and any safe tray required for the installation

In Brisbane homes, installation costs vary between electric and gas hot water systems. For businesses, costs are usually higher because of bigger hot water systems and more complex setups.

‍

Required Maintenance Differences Between Gas And Electric Hot Water Systems

Maintenance means keeping your hot water system working safely and efficiently through regular checks and upkeep. This helps prevent breakdowns and makes your hot water system last longer.

Gas hot water systems need servicing according to the manufacturer's schedule. In Queensland, gas servicing, repairs and testing must be carried out by a licensed gasfitter:

  • Have a licensed gasfitter inspect and clean the burner as specified for the model
  • Have the gasfitter check gas connections as part of the scheduled service
  • Keep ventilation unobstructed and have flue servicing carried out as specified by the manufacturer
  • For storage systems, follow the owner's guide for temperature-pressure relief valve checks and replacement

Electric storage hot water systems also need scheduled maintenance, even when they appear to be working normally:

  • Have an appropriately licensed professional inspect heating elements as required by the service schedule
  • Leave thermostat testing and electrical repairs to an appropriately licensed professional
  • Follow the manufacturer's tank and anode maintenance schedule
  • Check relief valves at the intervals specified in the owner's guide; do not wait for a fault

Only perform maintenance identified for owners in the model's manual and only where safely accessible. Relief-valve discharge can scald: stay clear of the outlet and never block the drain. Ask a licensed plumber if access or operation is unsafe or unclear. Rheem's owner-maintenance guidance explains this boundary.

‍

Average Lifespan Differences Between Gas And Electric Hot Water Systems

The lifespan of your hot water system is how long it will work well before it needs replacing. Both types of hot water systems can last many years when looked after properly.

Gas systems should not be assigned one lifespan based only on their fuel. For example, Rheem's gas-storage owner's guide (page 15) identifies water chemistry, pressure, water temperatures and usage patterns as factors affecting service life. Check the guidance for the selected model.

Electric storage systems also vary by model and operating conditions. Rheem's electric-storage owner's guide (page 15) identifies the same service-life factors. The energy source alone is not a reliable basis for claiming that electric or gas will always last longer.

The actual life of either hot water system depends on:

  • How much hot water you use each day
  • The water quality in your area
  • Water pressure and incoming water temperature
  • How well it's maintained over the years

‍

Heat-up Time Differences Between Gas And Electric Hot Water Systems

Storage heat-up time is the time needed to reheat water in the tank. It depends on how much water is being heated and the model's heating output. Rheem explains recovery rate as the amount of water reheated per hour at a stated temperature rise.

For gas storage systems, compare:

  • The model's rated recovery rate
  • The model's usable stored hot water capacity
  • The temperature rise used for the manufacturer's recovery rating
  • How the storage capacity and recovery rate match your household's demand

For electric storage systems, compare:

  • The volume of water being reheated and the element's power rating
  • When electricity is available under the system's supply schedule
  • The incoming water temperature and the temperature rise required
  • Whether an upper booster element heats only part of the tank

‍

Noise Level Differences Between Gas And Electric Hot Water Systems

Noise level means how much sound your hot water system makes while it's working. This can be important if your hot water system is near bedrooms or living areas.

Gas hot water systems can produce operating sounds. Rheem's guide to water-heater noise gives examples such as:

  • Sounds when the burner ignites
  • Water movement and pipework sounds as temperatures change

Electric resistance hot water systems have no burner, but can still make sounds:

  • Heating elements may hum during operation
  • Pipework can click as it expands and contracts with temperature changes

‍

What Are The Overall Pros And Cons When Comparing Gas And Electric Hot Water Systems?

At Mitchell Plumbing & Gas, we know that choosing between gas and electric hot water systems depends on what works best for your Brisbane home. Gas hot water systems shine when it comes to heating speed and running costs, but need more maintenance. Electric hot water systems are easier to install, but can cost more to run.

‍

What Are The Advantages Of Gas Hot Water When Compared To Electric Hot Water?

Gas hot water systems offer several benefits that make them popular in Brisbane homes. These advantages show why many households choose gas heating:

  • Gas storage models can offer faster recovery; compare the model ratings
  • Perfect for large families who use lots of hot water
  • Can handle multiple showers or appliances at once
  • Lower running costs if you have access to natural gas
  • Better performance on cold Brisbane mornings
  • Some gas storage models can keep heating during a power outage. Gas models requiring mains electricity, including many continuous-flow systems, need electrical power to operate. Check the selected model's requirements; Rheem explains the distinction.
  • More consistent water temperature

‍

What Are The Advantages Of Electric Hot Water When Compared To Gas Hot Water?

Electric hot water systems have their own set of benefits that suit many Brisbane households. Here's what makes electric hot water systems a good choice:

  • No gas emissions in your home
  • Simple installation without need for gas lines
  • Lower purchase and setup costs
  • Great for small homes and units
  • Less complicated maintenance needed
  • Needs suitable plumbing, electrical supply, drainage and service access
  • Easy to replace parts when needed
  • Safe option where gas isn't available
  • Works well with solar power hot water systems

‍

Recent Post

Burst pipe repair cost

Burst pipe repair cost

November 4, 2022
Mitchell Plumbing & Gas

Burst pipes can cause a lot of damage to your home and cost you a lot of money. burst pipes can be repaired, but it is important to know the

Most Energy Efficient Hot Water System in Australia

Most Energy Efficient Hot Water System in Australia

February 11, 2025
Mitchell Plumbing & Gas

Heat pump and solar hot water systems can reduce purchased energy compared with conventional electric resistance water heating. Compare suitable models using household demand, local climate, installation conditions, booster use and current energy tariffs.

250L (Litre) capacity Hot Water System for Sale: Supply and Installation in Brisbane

250L (Litre) capacity Hot Water System for Sale: Supply and Installation in Brisbane

February 11, 2025
Mitchell Plumbing & Gas

At Mitchell Plumbing & Gas, we bring you top-quality 250L hot water systems to meet your family's hot water needs. Our experienced Brisbane plumbers are ready to help you select and install the perfect hot water system for your home. Our full supply and installation package gives you professional installation by licensed plumbers, quality workmanship guarantee, manufacturer's warranty, and a compliance certificate.